So I recently saw this Ted talk where Blaise Agüera y Arcas shows great improvements the Google teams has made in computers working with neural networks. Basically what the team did was to find a way to interpret an image using neural networks to make an answer, for example take a picture of a bird and the computer could tell you that was a bird and which bird is it. Blaise explained the approach in a mathematical way: X is the picture of the bird, W is the neural network and Y the answer, so if we “multiply” X and W we could get Y. After a brilliant solution to the problem they managed to solve for Y, and that’s how we got Google Photos recognition and so forth.
BUT, then they started solving for the other letters, and that’s when it got weird. So now what they did was to give the computer a word (bird for example) and the picture, and the computer would create the neural network to get there. Same for X, they gave the word and the network and they would create an accurate picture. Still brilliant, bravo. However the conclusion Blaise made was that they could program perception, thus perception is a thing independent from the persons personality and it comes with the brain we all have.
I think this is partially true. Yes perception can be tricked to make people see different things (as perception exercises do) and almost all people fall for the same thing, but the kind of perception that leads to creativity does not work the same way (remember at the start of the talk Blaise said perception leads to creativity). I think, if we could really program perception I would be able to see the same man coming out of the marble as Michelangelo did, and obviously I can’t. If we could “solve” for perception I would get the same idea from a painting that my friend right next to me is getting, and it doesn’t work like that.
In the process of programming perception we are shutting our minds to all the other solutions this mathematical system has, and I fear that people would conform with “the solution” and start trusting only one of the ways of seeing the world as the only one. I don’t think google will actually do this, but in the seek for coding creativity we’ve just might taken a step back.
Thoughts?
